Review: Holiday Wishes – Jill Shalvis

Posted 16 October, 2017 by Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms in Reviews / 22 Comments

*I received a free copy of Holiday Wishes from via Edelweiss. This has in no way influenced my voluntary review, which is honest and unbiased *

Review: Holiday Wishes – Jill ShalvisHoliday Wishes Series: Heartbreaker Bay #4.5
on 7 November 2017
Pages: 128
4.5 Stars

When Sean O’Riley shows up at the Hartford Bed & Breakfast for his older brother’s bachelor weekend, he’s just hoping to make it through the weekend. What he’s not expecting is to come face to face with the woman he lost his virginity to a decade ago—a woman he’s never really forgotten.
The last time Lotti Hartford saw Sean, she told him she loved him while he said nothing. Now, ten years later, she’s just looking for a good time. For once, she wants to be the wild and free one, and Sean – the good time guy – is the perfect candidate.
But as the weekend continues, Sean realizes that after a lifetime of being the hook-up king, he’s ready to find happily-ever-after, and he wants it with Lotti. But will she open her heart to him again? As Christmas sweeps through the little B&B, he can only hope love and magic are in the air.

Holiday Wishes was a sweet, tender novella in one of my favorite Shalvis series, and I loved to see this more mature side of Sean.

Review - (un)Conventional Bookviews


While Holiday Wishes is a quite short story, the feel of the Heartbreaker Bay gang is very much present. The group of friends and family are away for a weekend of bachelor and bachelorette party for Pru and Finn. All organized by Sean, to the amazement of everyone. He has planned everything down to the smallest detail. Apart from the fact that his very first girlfriend, the one he let get away, is the innkeeper.

The easy banter between the characters, as well as their strong ties always makes Heartbreaker Bay the place to be. The story was romantic on more than one level, too, as there was an impromptu wedding Sean had to arrange.


Sean was so responsible and mature in Holiday Wishes, and I loved seeing him like this. He also showed more of his emotional side, which made me like him much more than usual.

Lotti was all alone, just waiting for her last guests to leave so she could go on a much needed vacation. Only, when Sean showed up as one of the guests, she got a huge blast from the past.

The other Heartbreaker Bay characters were present in Holiday Wishes, too, but they were on the sidelines for what became a beautiful second chance at love story.

Writing style :

Holiday Wishes is written in third person point of view, past tense. The story follows both Sean and Lotti closely, and I got to know them both on an intimate level. The pace is rather slow, and this worked well for the kind of story it was.

Feels :

I have such a huge love for second chance at love stories, so my feels were fully invested from the start. I felt the hope as soon as Sean did, and I also felt Lotti’s hesitation. And I also felt their off-the-charts attraction and chemistry, as well as all the unresolved feelings they both had for each other.

Fave Quotes - (un)Conventional Bookviews

After that, he’d turned to fighting, and not the good kind either. Finn, physically older by seven years, mentally older by about a hundred, had single-handedly saved Sean from just about every situation he’d ever landed himself in.

“Hold on.” Pru gave him a long look. “if you’re trying to say you don’t want to do this after talking me into it, then let me be clear and say that I will run you through with my umbrella while you sleep.” Finn blinked. “That was oddly specific and violent.”

Reading this book contributed to these challenges:

Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms

About Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms

Linda is an English as foreign language teacher and has a Master's degree in English Language and Literature. She's an avid reader, blogger, compulsive one-clicker and a genre omnivore. Ever since she learnt how to read she has been seen with a book or two in her hands everywhere she goes.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 9,077 other subscribers

22 responses to “Review: Holiday Wishes – Jill Shalvis

  1. I adore this series so much! I’m excited to read this even though I despise novellas. I’m so happy to hear about Sean being responsible and mature here. Can’t wait!

  2. Ailyn Koay

    oddly specific and violent, why does he have to be sleeping? then again, at least she didn’t say that she’ll open it once it’s in… ewwwwwwwww

    haha this is a strange romance story, even for Santa

  3. I just read this last night and liked it so much! So much more than the other novella in the series. I loved seeing Sean be all responsible and having Finn’s back, too. Loved it so much! I can’t wait to read About That Kiss now!

  4. I like a slow pace in a romance especially a short one. It makes it feel more full length. I am now adding this series to my TBR because I love the connection these types of books have with the other characters in the series. Makes it feel like home.

    Awesome review, my friend! (((hugs)))

  5. Awesome review, Lexxie. Glad that you enjoyed it. This book has been on my radar. I’m planning on reading lots of holiday books next month and maybe Christmas books since we’re closer to charismas now.

  6. You know I’m a sucker for second chance romances as well, wifey, and I’m rather a fan of Shalvis. She’s in my queue for November/December as I make a push to catch up in series. 🙂 So happy you loved this one!
    {{{hugs & love}}}

  7. I also got this one for review, but haven’t read it yet. I am glad to hear the whole gang is present in this story and it will be interesting to see Sean gets his romance. That’s nice you get to see more of Sean’s emotional side in this book. And I enjoy a good second chance romance. I’ll hope I can read this one soon. Great review!

Thanks for commenting - chat soon!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.