Review: Written in my Own Heart’s Blood – Diana Gabaldon

Posted 23 June, 2014 by Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms in Reviews / 8 Comments

Review: Written in my Own Heart’s Blood – Diana Gabaldon |
3 Stars

WRITTEN IN MY OWN HEART’S BLOOD is the eighth novel in the world-famous OUTLANDER series. In June of 1778, the world turns upside-down. The British army withdraws from Philadelphia, George Washington prepares to move from Valley Forge in pursuit, and Jamie Fraser comes back from the dead to discover that his best friend has married Jamie’s wife. The ninth Earl of Ellesmere discovers to his horror that he is in fact the illegitimate son of the newly-resurrected Jamie Fraser (a rebel _and_ a Scottish criminal!) and Jamie’s nephew Ian Murray discovers that his new-found cousin has an eye for Ian’s Quaker betrothed.

Meanwhile, Claire Fraser deals with an asthmatic duke, Benedict Arnold, and the fear that one of her husbands may have murdered the other. And in the 20th century, Jamie and Claire’s daughter Brianna is thinking that things are probably easier in the 18th century: her son has been kidnapped, her husband has disappeared into the past, and she’s facing a vicious criminal with nothing but a stapler in her hand. Fortunately, her daughter has a miniature cricket bat and her mother’s pragmatism.

The best of historical fiction with a Moebius twist, WRITTEN IN MY OWN HEART’S BLOOD weaves the fibers of a family’s life through the tapestry of historical drama.

Written in my Own Heart’s Blood is the 8th book in the Outlander series, and I, for one had been waiting impatiently for quite a while to finally get to read this installment. For once, though, I wasn’t completely swept off my feet, and as I start writing this review, I don’t even know how I am going to rate it yet.

My Written in my Own Heart’s Blood Review:

Written in my Own Heart’s Blood has several story lines, which is no problem for the fans who have been following the series from the start. We follow Jamie and Clare, of course, and we also follow Brianna and her kids, Roger and Buck, Fergus, Ian and Rachel, Lord John and William. There are more timelines than usual to keep track of again, and I think this is partly why I might not have enjoyed myself as much as I thought I would. I was also a little upset about the fact that Jamie and Clare were not together for the beginning of Written in my Own Heart’s Blood, and Brianna and Roger were hardly seen together at all – they were literally separated by over a century.

Another thing I noticed and was a little appalled by while reading Written in my Own Heart’s Blood is that there seems to be no single book in the Outlander series where there is no mention of anal sex being performed very violently. Really, what is up with that? Was this something that was so common in the late 18th century that it has to be mentioned several times in each book? In this one, it was a prostitute who was being forced to have anal sex with one of her paying customers who enjoyed hurting the girls he paid for, and he talked about it at length before actually going to a room with her.

Of course, I loved the tender scenes between Clare and Jamie in Written in my Own Heart’s Blood. They are still awesome together, even if I felt that Jamie has mellowed a little bit in some ways. They are starting to get older, and I think that came across quite often throughout the story. I also have to point out that for such a long story – 848 pages is quite long, right? – I think I would have been happier with Written in my Own Heart’s Blood if it had been maybe ten pages or a chapter longer. The ending was abrupt, and I really wanted to know what would happen right there. At the same time, I was peeved that this evidently is being kept for the next book, even if that wasn’t necessary in my opinion.

After following both Brianna and Roger in their adventures to find Jem, and keep him safe from Cameron – in different centuries – their story was not complete, as the readers never got to see how they managed to continue their journey, or what happened to them for a very long time. I also keep thinking it’s strange that Jamie and Clare would be present, and important in so many big historical happenings. In Written in my Own Heart’s Blood, they were in Philadelphia when the British army was there, and when a retreat was started. I understand the want to have the main characters being part of things, but it is starting to become a little too much by now.

The writing in Written in my Own Heart’s Blood is flawless, I have to say this as well. When the readers get Clare’s point of view, it is written in first person, and for other characters it’s in third person point of view. Even with all the different characters we follow, it is not hard to understand just who we are following at any given time. Almost all of the characters are well fleshed out, even some of the newer ones that were introduced in this installment. However, I wish there would have been a little bit more about Jenny and Ian, as we did not really get to see their reunion, or any intimate conversations between the two of them.

After all this, I am still on the fence with how to rate Written in my Own Heart’s Blood! I guess that means it should get a three star rating. In the middle – not awesome but not awful either. I probably will not have the next book in the Outlander on pre-order, though.

Some of my favorite quotes:

Tears ran down his face with the sweat of the summer day; he didn’t mind it, only stopping now and then to wipe his nose on his sleeve. He’d tied a rolled kerchief round his head to keep the hair and the stinging sweat out of his eyes; it was sopping before he’d added more than twenty stones to each of the cairns.

“We thought you were dead, you bloody arsehole!” he said, furious. “Both of us! Dead! And we – we – took too much to drink one night – very much to much… We spoke of you… and… Damn you, neither of us was making love to the other – we were both fucking you!”

The phrase “Blessed are those who have not seen but have believed” floated through his head. It was maybe not the believing that was the blessing: it was the not having to look. Seeing, sometimes, was bloody awful.

Lexxie signature (un)Conventional Bookviews





Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms

About Linda @ (un)Conventional Bookworms

Linda is an English as foreign language teacher and has a Master's degree in English Language and Literature. She's an avid reader, blogger, compulsive one-clicker and a genre omnivore. Ever since she learnt how to read she has been seen with a book or two in her hands everywhere she goes.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 9,075 other subscribers

8 responses to “Review: Written in my Own Heart’s Blood – Diana Gabaldon

  1. LOL on the anal sex.

    Ouch! My poor a-hole! Well I saw in one of those documentaries that it was quite common during the day esp for “virgins” who wants to be sexually active but are preserving their cherry for their husband. But no to violence!

    I haven’t read this but I’m looking forward to the TV series instead. I’m glad you still enjoyed this one, at 8 books, it seems she’s still inspired by her world and characters.

    • That’s very interesting, Braine, and I guess kind of understandable as well. But I agree, there shouldn’t be any violence to go with this, ever.

      I look forward to the TV series as well, especially because it seems as if Gabaldon is quite involved with everything that is going on. I love the characters, and the time travel elements are extremely well done 🙂

      Thanks for stopping by!

  2. Ohh, I’m sorry this installment wasn’t a satisfying read, Lexxie. That really stinks as this is a favorite series for you. 🙁 Is this a case where the author is dragging the series on when it should end? It makes you wonder what the author and her editor were thinking. I haven’t read The Outlander series although it’s been highly recommended. Once I do start the series, I don’t think I’ll be in a hurry to read this one. Lovely review, though.

    **BIG HUGS** Happy Monday!

    • Oh no, not at all! I want more of the series, and I think there are still many stories to be told, too! I don’t know why I wasn’t as enchanted with MOBY as I’ve been with the other books in the series, Brandee.
      Thanks for stopping by!

  3. Thanks for the interesting review, Lexxie! I really did love Written In My Own Heart’s Blood — but couldn’t even figure out how to begin reviewing it, so I gave it 5 stars on Goodreads and left it at that! Eight books in, I feel like the series is still going strong. I wouldn’t have minded it being longer, though. Like you, I wanted to know what happened in the next few moments after the ending! I agree that Diana Gabaldon’s writing is flawless… and can’t wait for the TV show!

    Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies recently posted: Flashback Friday: Don’t Let’s Go To The Dogs Tonight
    • A lot of things were happening, for sure! And I can’t wait to read more in the series, I’m in no way put off of it. And I agree it’s still going strong, there were just some things that did bother me a little…
      Can you imagine how the next one will start? And I can’t wait for the TV show, either! I hope I’ll be able to get it on iTunes 🙂
      Thanks for stopping by.

Thanks for commenting - chat soon!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.